- 1 Hank Aaron
- 2 Luis Aparicio
- 3 Bob Aspromonte
- 4 Ernie Banks
- 5 Steve Barber
- 6 Earl Battey
- 7 Larry "Yogi" Berra
- 8 Ken Boyer
- 9 Lew Burdette
- 10 Johnny Callison
- 11 Norm Cash
- 12 Orlando Cepeda
- 13 Dean Chance
- 14 Tom Cheney
- 15 Roberto Clemente
- 16 Rocky Colavito
- 17 Choo Choo Coleman
- 18 Roger Craig
- 19 Joe Cunningham
- 20 Don Drysdale
- 21 Dick Farrell
|
- 22 Whitey Ford
- 23 Nelson Fox
- 24 Tito Francona
- 25 Jim Gentile
- 26 Tony Gonzalez
- 27 Dick Groat
- 28 Ray Herbert
- 29 Chuck Hinton
- 30 Don Hoak
- 31 Frank Howard
- 32 Ken Hubbs
- 33 Joey Jay
- 34 Al Kaline
- 35 Harmon Killebrew
- 36 Sandy Koufax
- 37 Harvey Kuenn
- 38 Jim Landis
- 39 Art Mahaffey
- 40 Frank Malzone
- 41 Mickey Mantle
- 42 Roger Maris
|
- 43 Eddie Mathews
- 44 Willie Mays
- 45 Bill Mazeroski
- 46 Ken McBride
- 47 Wally Moon
- 48 Stan Musial
- 49 Charlie Neal
- 50 Bill O'Dell
- 51 Milt Pappas
- 52 Camilo Pascual
- 53 Jimmy Piersall
- 54 Vada Pinson
- 55 Brooks Robinson
- 56 Frank Robinson
- 57 Pete Runnels
- 58 Ron Santo
- 59 Norm Siebern
- 60 Warren Spahn
- 61 Lee Thomas
- 62 Leon Wagner
- 63 Billy Williams
- 64 Maurice Wills
|